Quebec Tax Savings Plan Comparator 2026
Serious decision-making tool: 3 return scenarios, management fees, disbursement phase, risk profile and 500 Monte Carlo simulations. Doesn’t give a single magic number, but a realistic range to help you decide.
🎯 Start with a situation close to yours
Your settings
📋 Financial Profile
📈 Risk Profile & Return
🎯 Objective & strategy i
Fill in your settings to get a recommendation.
Final net value by plan — 3 scenarios
Growth over time (realistic)
Monte Carlo Distribution — Winning Regime
| Diet | Total Contribution | Credit/subv. | Accrued Fees | Pessimistic | Realistic | Optimistic |
|---|
📤 Disbursement phase (winning plan + other assets)
🔍 Assumptions used (full transparency)
- Fill in your parameters to see the assumptions applied.
Why the chosen diet changes everything
Investments earn three types of income: interest, dividends and capital gains. In Quebec, this income is not taxed in the same way. But within a registered plan (RRSP, TFSA, FSASA, RESP, VRSP), this distinction disappears : everything grows tax-free.
| Type of income | Taxable inclusion | Effective MMR rate 50% |
|---|---|---|
| Interest (GICs, bonds, savings accounts) | 100% | ≈ 50% |
| Eligible dividends (large Canadian corporations) | ~ 138% gross, with tax credit | ≈ 36% |
| Non-eligible dividends (SMEs) | ~ 115% gross, reduced credit | ≈ 47% |
| Capital gain (shares, resold funds) | 50% | ≈ 25% |
Within an RRSP, TFSA, FHSA, RESP, VRSP or RDSP, the type of income is no longer of tax importance. This is the major advantage of these vehicles.
The silent impact of management fees
Over 30 years, a management fee of 2% vs. 0.5% can cost you more than $100,000 on a $200,000 portfolio. This is the most expensive blind spot in financial planning.
| Annual Fee | Typical Product Type | Final Capital $200K × 30 Years @ 6% Gross | Total Cost of Fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.25% | Index ETF (XAW, VEQT, ZGRO) | $1,026,000 | $50,000 |
| 0.75% | Bank Index Fund (Tangerine) | $934,000 | $142,000 |
| 1.50% | Mutual Fund (median MER) | $807,000 | $269,000 |
| 2.25% | Back-end sales charge fund | $695,000 | $381,000 |
The fees add up: the fund’s MER (0.1% to 2.5%) + advisor fees (0% to 1.5%) + transaction fees. Always ask for the total MER and consulting fee before signing. The simulator above includes a fresh field — test the actual impact on your case.
Risk: what the “average” numbers hide
An average return of 6% does not mean 6% every year. The markets are -20% one year, +30% the next. This volatility changes everything, especially when you cash out.
Cautious profile
60% bonds / 40% equities
- Expected return: ~ 4%
- Volatility (standard deviation): ± 4%
- Worst year ever: ~ −10%
- Suitable: short horizon (< 7 years), strong risk aversion
Balanced profile
40% bonds / 60% equities
- Expected return: ~5.5%
- Volatility: ± 8%
- Worst year ever: ~ −20%
- Suitable: 7-15 year horizon, moderate tolerance
Aggressive profile
20% bonds / 80% equities
- Expected return: ~7.5%
- Volatility: ± 14%
- Worst year ever: ~ −35%
- Suitable: 15+ year horizon, high tolerance
Disbursement phase: the great forgotten one
Accumulating $1 million is useless if you deplete it in 12 years. The withdrawal sequence and smart order between your accounts can double the length of your savings.
| Strategy | Advantage | When to use | it
|---|---|---|
| RRSP first, TFSA second | Avoid high MMR on large RRSP later | retirement MMT < current MMR, no employer pension |
| Bracket filling | Fills the bottom 27% each year with a Standard RRSP | recommended by financial planners |
| TFSA first | RRSP custody for inheritance, tax deferral | If large estate expected (RRSP 100% taxable at death) |
| Non-registered first | Realizes low-taxed capital gains early | If large non-registered account + taxed RRSP/TFSA |
The simulator above calculates the sustainable annual withdrawal based on an actuarial annuity (net return after inflation × fees), and recommends the smart order based on your current MMR vs. retirement.
The 6 diets in detail
Each plan has a goal. Understanding how they work prevents you from using the wrong vehicle.
RRSP — Retirement
The Registered Retirement Savings Plan allows you to invest while saving on taxes, most often in anticipation of retirement.
- Contribute reduces your tax immediately (to your MMR)
- Investment grows tax-free
- You pay tax on the amounts withdrawn (at the MMR of the moment)
- 2026 Cap: 18% of Revenue, max $32,490
- Contribution deadline: March 1, 2027 for the year 2026
TFSA — Full flexibility
The Tax-Free Savings Account grows your investments tax-free at the end.
- Contributing does NOT reduce your taxes
- Investment grows tax-free
- No tax on withdrawals
- 2026 limit: $7,000/year, entitlements accruing for 18 years
- Maximum life for 2026 (born in 1991 or earlier): $102,000
FHSA — 1st property
The Tax-Free First Home Savings Account combines RRSP + TFSA benefits.
- Tax-deductible contributions (such as RRSPs)
- Tax-deferred growth
- Tax-free withdrawals for a 1st home (such as a TFSA)
- Cap: $8,000/year, $40,000 lifetime
- As a couple: each spouse can contribute → $16,000/year, $80,000 for life
- Must be used within 15 years of opening
RESP — Child’s Education
The Registered Education Savings Plan attracts up to 30% government grants (CESG + QESI).
- Contributing does not reduce your taxes
- Federal CESG 20% on the first $2,500/year (max $500/year, $7,200 lifetime)
- QESI Quebec 10% on the first $2,500/year (max $250/year, $3,600 lifetime)
- Tax-deferred growth
- Withdrawals: Your contributions come out tax-free; the student pays income tax + subsidies (at his MMT, often ~15%)
- Life limit: $50,000 per child
VRSP — Employer Plan
The Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan is a retirement vehicle offered by certain employers in Quebec, based on payroll deductions.
- Payroll deductions reduce taxes at source
- Tax-deferred growth (such as RRSPs)
- Taxed withdrawals (such as RRSPs)
- Voluntary participation, you can opt out
- Management fees are often lower than an individual RRSP (employer-negotiated benefit)
RDSP — Safety of a person with a disability
The Registered Disability Savings Plan provides long-term financial security for a person who is eligible for the Disability Credit.
- Contributing does not reduce your taxes
- The government is adding the CDSG (grant) up to $3,500/year and the CDSG (bond) up to $1,000/year for low incomes
- Tax-deferred growth
- Your contributions come out tax-free; the person pays income tax + subsidies
- Life ceiling: $200,000
- Grants available up to age 49 of the beneficiary
Combined strategies (tested in the simulator)
No diet alone is optimal for the majority. Real strategies combine several diets depending on the profile.
| Logical Strategy | Ideal Profile | |
|---|---|---|
| 50% RRSP / 50% TFSA | Balance immediate deduction + long-term flexibility | Employee 30-50 years old, MMR 30-37%, retirement horizon |
| RRSP max → TFSA | Maximizes RRSP First Deduction (limits), High Income TFSA Surplus | , MMR≥ 37%, Savings Capacity ≥ $12,000/year |
| FHSA → RRSP | FHSA $8,000/year for 5 years ($40,000), then RRSP then | 1st Home Buyer 25-35 years |
| RESP 2500 + RRSP + TFSA | RESP for subv 30%, RRSP for deduction, TFSA for the rest Parent, | young child + savings capacity≥ $8,000/year |
| Auto Optim (according to MMR) | The algorithm chooses the best ratio according to your current MMR vs retirement | All profiles, to be validated with a F.Pl. |
2026 Limits and Fees — Summary
| Plan | Maximum annual contribution | Lifetime limit | Deadline |
|---|---|---|---|
| RRSP | 18% of income, max $32,490None | March 1, 2027 | |
| TFSA | $7,000Cumulative | for 18 years ($102,000 for those born in 1991) | December 31, 2026 |
| FHSA $ | 8,000 | $40,000December | 31, 2026 |
| RESP | None, but Full CESG on $2,500 | $50,000/child | December 31, 2026 |
| CESG + QESI | $500 + $250/year | $7,200 + $3,600December | 31, 2026 |
| RDSP | None | $200,000December | 31, 2026 |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to contribute to an RRSP or TFSA in 2026?
Why do my calculations show 3 different results?
How do management fees impact my bottom line?
What is the difference between nominal and real return?
What happens if I exceed the contribution limits?
How does the spousal RRSP work?
What is the optimal order to withdraw in retirement?
Is the FHSA really better for buying my first home?
How much does the RESP earn in grants?
Who can help me validate my strategy?
2026 Settings VerifiedUp-to-date RRSP, TFSA, FHSA, RESP and combined Quebec + federal MMT brackets.
Transparent methodologyAssumptions displayed (yield, fees, inflation, MMR) — no black boxes.
Neutral toolNo hidden commissions, no collection of personal data, open calculation code in the page.
Other Assur360 simulators
Need a human opinion to validate your strategy?
A financial planner or investment advisor registered with the AMF can analyze your entire situation (income, debts, plans, taxation, estate) and build an optimized plan. First consultation, often free.